Spice Week – Day 5: Butternut Squash Soup with Allspice

Good evening! The last miner was just pulled to surface in Chile – it just takes my breath away (and not in the Top Gun/Tom Cruise kind of way!). I’ve been glued to this story since the rescue began, and so glad to see a happy ending.

Today was the fifth day of trying my new spices in new recipes, which I’ve dubbed the MegGoesNomNom Spice Week (yes, this is my cheese-tastic life! I’ve owned it!). In case you missed the spice-related events leading up to today, here are some links to catch you up:

Today of course, was time for yet another of my new spices – Allspice. And not only a new spice, but this was also a new recipe, and further, a new food for me! I made Butternut Squash Soup, which, even as a squash-lover, is something I’ve never tried before. I found an interesting recipe to try (click here to see the recipe), chock full of all sorts of ingredients, one of which was Allspice.

The first few steps involved frying slice slices of diced bacon up, setting them aside, and then sauteing carrot, celery, onion, apple, and garlic in the drippings. This past weekend I chopped the veggies up so they were all ready to go – a great weeknight time-saver! After several minutes of saute time, I added 32 oz. of fat-free reduced-sodium chicken broth (College Inn brand seems to have the lowest sodium content of all the brands that I can find at Meijer – they are also one of the least expensive brands – score.)


At this point, it was time for the star ingredient to shine – four 12-ounce packages of frozen squash (very affordable and SO much easier than peeling/chopping a fresh butternut squash – though I do feel slightly guilty for not taking advantage of fresh seasonal produce). I attempted to defrost the squash by placing the packages in the fridge the night before, but they barely thawed, and it ended up being totally fine just throwing the frozen squash into the broth.

Once all the ingredients were all warm and “happy,” as Emeril might say, I let the soup simmer for about 20 minutes, filling my home with yummy fall aromas of squash (or maybe it was the bacon that smelled good! 😉 ).

After 20 minutes you’ll have something that looks like the below picture:

This is the point at which there is a chunk of missing documentation of the soup-making process – due to boiling-hot, liquefied butternut squash flying all over my kitchen and body, followed by lots of yelps. It wasn’t pretty. Luckily it wasn’t a large volume of squash. Basically what has to happen to your soup at this point is that you need to spoon it into your blender, in batches (that is KEY! SMALL batches kids, trust me, or your kitchen will look like mine 😉 ), to puree all your veggies and create a thick, luscious soup texture. Once everything was blended and back in the pot, I added the following ingredients (including the spice of the day – Allspice!).

I probably added 3 or 4 times as much honey as the recipe called for, as I tasted it and it wasn’t quite as sweet as I’d have liked. It was quite savory, and I was hoping for a hint of sweetness – easily remedied by a few additional honey squirts. I also added extra nutmeg; partly because I love it, but mostly because it contains the name “meg.”

Here is the final product, garnished with bacon and half-and-half. Gorgeous!

Perfect for a fall day, amirite? At first I wasn’t sure I was a huge fan. The flavor packed a PUNCH, from all the different ingredients, but with every additional bite I took, I loved this soup more and more. By the end I was raving! So scrumptious, and packed full of veggies.

To accompany the soup, we had grilled ham & cheese-us. No cheese-us for us, but maybe a flying spaghetti monster on there somewhere. (I’m predicting that only a small fraction of my audience will understand that last sentence.) I must give credit where credit is due, and Tom must receive credit for assembling these sandwiches, before I grilled them up. Nice work T!

Now I really want to watch Top Gun.

♪♫ Currently listening to: Take My Breath Away – Berlin.

3 thoughts on “Spice Week – Day 5: Butternut Squash Soup with Allspice

  1. Pingback: Meal Planning for the Week of October 6–October 12 « Meg.Goes.Nom.Nom.

  2. Pingback: Meal Planning for the Week of October 6–October 12 « Meg.Goes.Nom.Nom.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s